16 independently run vacation rentals in New York, run by 3 local hosts. Across Rochester, Cooperstown, Livingston Manor, Newfane, Cutchogue and East Marion. Book direct on each host's own site, with no guest service fees.
New York spans a wide sweep of terrain, from forested uplands and broad river valleys to lake country and the Atlantic’s low shores. The towns here trace that arc: Rochester and Cooperstown inland, Livingston Manor in the mountains, Newfane near big water, Cutchogue and East Marion along the North Fork. Expect small-town main streets, working farms, quiet coves and long horizons. Summer brings open water and green trails, winter brings snow and clear air, and fall turns the trees.
This collection gathers 16 places across those settings. It includes cabins, quiet retreats, design-forward stays, spots surrounded by nature, and places built for groups, plus one with a story. Capacities run from 3 to 20 guests, and 3 host sites offer more than one stay. Choose woods, vineyard country or a lakeside edge.
Search live availability in New York

Newfane, NY
A quiet woodland retreat near Mount Snow.
sleeps 4
At a glance: Sleeps 4. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Newfane, NY
A cozy woodland retreat by the slopes.
sleeps 4
At a glance: Sleeps 4. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Rochester, NY
A cozy retreat for movie nights.
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Rochester, NY
A peaceful getaway for family and friends.
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Rochester, NY
A serene retreat in the heart of it all.
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Rochester, NY
A welcoming setting for family gatherings.
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Rochester, NY
A cozy retreat in the heart of Rochester.
sleeps 5
At a glance: Sleeps 5. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Livingston Manor, NY
Nature's Playground: Fly Fishing & Kayaking on 47 Acres of Bliss
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. Pets welcome.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Livingston Manor, NY
Serene Retreat Near Bethel: Your Escape to Tranquility
sleeps 3
At a glance: Sleeps 3. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Cooperstown, New York
The Ultimate All-Star Stay
sleeps 16
At a glance: Sleeps 16. Pets welcome.
Book direct on cooperstown-dream-house.com

Cutchogue, NY
A north fork summer retreat overlooking the Great Peconic Bay
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Haven's read: Quiet and restful. Immersed in nature. Good for families with children.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Southampton, NY
A chic and cozy house on a quiet block close to Southampton village
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Haven's read: Good for families with children.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

East Marion, NY
A beachfront coastal cottage overlooking Gardiners Bay in East Marion
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Haven's read: Quiet and restful. Immersed in nature. Good for couples. Good for families with children.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com
South Fallsburg, NY
All Year-Heated Pool • Game Room • Hot Tub • Sauna • Cold Plunge Sleeps 20+
sleeps 20
At a glance: Sleeps 20. Pets welcome.
Book direct on fallsburgretreat.com

New York, NY
Luxury penthouse in Midtown West
sleeps 8
At a glance: Sleeps 8. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

Cooperstown, NY
A baseball lover's dream retreat.
sleeps 14
At a glance: Sleeps 14. No pets.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com
Independent hosts with more than one stay here run their own booking sites. Each links to the host's site, where every home they manage is listed.
Updated . Listings and counts come from each host's live site.