2 independently run vacation rentals surrounded by nature in New York. 2 suit groups, 2 are quiet, 1 is design-forward. Book direct on each host's own site, with no guest service fees.

Cutchogue, NY
A north fork summer retreat overlooking the Great Peconic Bay
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Haven's read: Quiet and restful. Immersed in nature. Good for families with children.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com

East Marion, NY
A beachfront coastal cottage overlooking Gardiners Bay in East Marion
sleeps 6
At a glance: Sleeps 6. No pets.
Haven's read: Quiet and restful. Immersed in nature. Good for couples. Good for families with children.
Book direct on bookwithhaven.com
Updated . Listings and counts come from each host's live site.