Compare for hosts
Plum Guide alternative for hosts: Book With Haven vs Plum Guide
Plum Guide is a curated luxury marketplace: it vets the home, sells the stay to its own audience, charges a 3% host fee plus a guest service fee of up to 22% (or a host-only fee of 16.5%–18.5%), and asks that your own website never undercut it. Haven is the platform that runs your rental business — your own site and checkout, the guest relationship, your terms, upsells, loyalty and marketing — and gets your property found everywhere.
Competitor facts checked
5.0on Capterra · 6 reviews, September 2026Plum Guide is the marketplace for hosts whose homes pass a human test. It says it accepts only the top 3% of the homes it reviews, lists more than 30,000 of them across 40-plus destinations, sends a Home Critic to visit before awarding the Plum Award, and runs a matchmaking team that personally contacts guests and accounts for almost 75% of bookings. That curation is real, and so is the premium demand it brings. Based on publicly available information as of October 2026, its Host Agreement (updated 17 July 2026) offers two fee structures: a split fee of typically 3% of the accommodation charges from the host plus a guest service fee of up to 22% that Plum keeps, or a host-only fee of typically 16.5%–18.5%, in each case plus applicable sales taxes. A one-time onboarding fee of £300, €300 or $400 plus sales taxes is deducted from the first payout.
That is the marketplace trade: it owns the introduction, sets the terms, and charges the same fee on the fifth stay as on the first. With Plum the trade is written plainly. Hosts may not list at a higher nightly rate or extra-service fee than on any other platform, including their own website, and a knowing breach can be charged as the price difference plus £50, €50 or $70. A host cancellation carries a penalty of 20% of what the guest paid on top of the forfeited payout. And the circumvention clause bars a host from accepting an extension or a future stay from a Plum-introduced guest off the platform. Those are reasonable terms for a marketplace that invests in vetting each home; they are also the clearest statement of who the guest belongs to.
Book With Haven is the Shopify of short-term rentals. It is not another marketplace competing with Plum Guide for your listing — it is the platform behind every channel you sell on: a branded booking site on your own domain with 0% commission, a guest CRM that knows every guest by their real email, the rental agreement, ID check and deposit you decide on, upsells, a loyalty program, automated remarketing, and the same guidebook for guests who booked on a marketplace or direct. Your property is found in Haven’s AI stay search, on Google, and by ChatGPT and Claude — and your Plum Guide listing keeps running through your PMS or calendar sync. One business, every channel, your rules.
Book With Haven vs Plum Guide, at a glance
The platform that runs a rental business across every channel: branded site and checkout, guest CRM, guidebooks, agreements and deposits, upsells, loyalty, marketing, tasks.
A curated luxury marketplace that accepts roughly the top 3% of the homes it reviews and sells the stay to its own audience on its terms, with a matchmaking team behind almost three-quarters of bookings. Strong for premium demand; not built to run the business behind the listing.
No per-booking commission and no guest service fee on any plan (standard Stripe fees apply).
Split fee: typically 3% of the accommodation charges from the host plus a guest service fee of up to 22% that Plum keeps. Host-only: typically 16.5%–18.5% of the accommodation charges. Both plus applicable sales taxes, per the Host Agreement as of October 2026.
Your price. Haven adds no guest fee, and you can show guests the real savings against the same stay on an OTA.
Your rate plus a Plum service fee of up to 22% of the total accommodation charges plus sales taxes on split-fee listings; the Guest Terms state only “up to 22%” and the exact percentage is not published, as of October 2026.
Free to build for as long as you like; pay only when you publish.
Listing is free, but a one-time onboarding fee of £300, €300, $400, 3,000 DKK or 1,500 ILS plus applicable sales taxes is deducted from the first payout after the first check-in, as of October 2026.
Every guest’s real email, phone and profile in your own CRM, with every stay they have made with you — from direct bookings and, through the guidebook, from marketplace stays too.
The host receives the guest’s contact details only after a confirmed booking, and the Host Agreement’s circumvention clause bars accepting off-platform bookings, extensions or future stays from a Plum-introduced guest, as of October 2026.
Built-in guest CRM with smart remarketing — local-event, gap-night, price-drop and listing-updated campaigns — plus loyalty points that bring guests back direct, with no commission on the repeat stay.
A guest Plum introduced stays a Plum guest: a direct extension or future stay counts as circumvention under the Host Agreement, with the fee that would have applied recoverable from payouts, and a repeat stay through Plum carries the same fee as the first. No host-run remarketing or loyalty, as of October 2026.
Your direct rate is yours to set. Haven asks for no parity with any channel, and you can show guests the real savings against the same stay on an OTA.
Hosts may not list at a higher nightly rate or extra-service fee than on any other platform, including their own website; if Plum believes a host knowingly listed at a higher daily rate it may charge the price difference plus £50, €50 or $70 in compensation, as of October 2026.
Any cancellation policy you write, including non-refundable, plus payment schedules (deposit at booking, up to five later payments), instant book or request-to-book, and your own minimum-stay and advance-booking rules.
A menu of named policies — the Guest Terms list Firm, Reasonable, Relaxed, Super Firm and Super Firm 30- and 60-day; the help centre names Relaxed, Firm and SuperFirm — with the refund window of each not documented publicly. A host cancellation costs a penalty of 20% of what the guest paid plus the forfeited payout, waived only within 24 hours of confirmation and more than seven full days before arrival, or when the guest is rehomed to Plum’s satisfaction, as of October 2026.
E-signed rental agreement, Stripe Identity verification and a refundable security deposit hold, each on or off per listing — and optionally on your Airbnb and Vrbo stays through the guidebook.
The host sets a deposit amount; damage must be reported within 48 hours of departure with evidence within seven days, and the deposit is returned within 14 days. Plum runs Onfido identity verification on instant-book guests itself. A host rental agreement is not documented, as of October 2026.
Your house rules as written, a checkout checklist shown per booking channel, and any fee or policy you choose to disclose and enforce on your own bookings.
House rules are published on the listing; no end-of-stay cleaning fee may be charged to guests, and Plum may remove a listing for any reason under the Host Agreement, as of October 2026.
Any host, any property — no inventory review or luxury threshold. Your guests see your own brand and your own reviews.
Only about the top 3% of homes reviewed are accepted, after a Home Critic visit and the Plum Award — a genuine strength for guests and for the hosts who pass, and a gate most properties will not, as of October 2026.
Your own site on your own domain, a free place in Haven’s plain-language AI stay search, Google and Bing through the built-in SEO scorecard, and ChatGPT and Claude through Haven’s open search API and MCP server — alongside the marketplace listings you keep.
Found on Plum Guide — a premium audience across 40-plus destinations with a matchmaking team that contacts guests personally — ranked by Plum, with priority visibility in search reserved for hosts who list exclusively; the guest relationship begins and ends on Plum.
Design-forward branded pages on your own domain, with branded guidebooks, emails and printed materials — the guest remembers you.
Your home appears inside Plum’s brand and carries the Plum Award; guests remember Plum Guide.
Create and sell your own experiences and add-ons with 0% Haven commission — quantities with real inventory, time slots and event seats, party-size pricing, deposits, and quote requests — sold pre-booking, at checkout, and in the guest guide. AI-assisted setup and import from any website included.
No host add-on catalog at checkout is documented; extra-service fees fall under the same parity rule as the nightly rate, and end-of-stay cleaning fees may not be charged to guests, as of October 2026.
Opt-in loyalty points on every direct booking, spendable at any of your listings and applied automatically at checkout; four automatic rewards emails (points ready, reminder, expiring soon, last call) with the bookings they bring back; optional inactivity expiry with guest protections; and one program across teammates’ or agency clients’ listings, funded so their payouts stay whole. Included on every plan.
No host-run loyalty program, and no Plum loyalty program is mentioned on its homepage or help pages as of October 2026. Trade press reported a Chase Travel partnership in April 2026 (card points on Plum bookings made through Chase Travel), which Haven records as reported, not confirmed.
Digital guidebooks and a mobile stay guide capture the booker’s and co-guests’ emails into a built-in guest CRM with smart remarketing — local-event, gap-night, price-drop, and listing-updated campaigns.
Signed-in guests can message the host from the listing before booking, and the host’s contact details are sent to the guest in the confirmation email; no guidebook product and no guest CRM are documented, as of October 2026.
Free guest screenings on every plan, plus optional Screen & Protect damage protection of up to $50,000 on eligible bookings via Truvi ($8 per booked night, paid by the guest at checkout or by the host).
Onfido identity verification for instant-book guests and a host-set security deposit with a 48-hour damage-reporting window; no damage-protection product beyond the deposit is documented, as of October 2026.
Haven is a direct-booking layer, not a 30+ OTA channel manager. Native two-way connectors for Hospitable, Guesty, Lodgify, Hostfully, OwnerRez, and Track. Any other PMS syncs listing content, photos, prices, availability, and reservations through Airbnb — the same data the PMS already publishes there. Haven bookings write back through native APIs, or via the Haven iCal feed added in the PMS for via-Airbnb connections.
Plum Guide is one channel. Non-exclusive hosts keep calendars in sync by pasting iCal links (its host page names Airbnb, Booking.com and Vrbo), and its help centre lists 15 PMS and channel-manager connections plus a Plum Guide API for availability and nightly prices, as of October 2026.
Native two-way connectors for Hospitable, Guesty, Lodgify, Hostfully, OwnerRez, and Track. Any other PMS — Hostaway, Hostex, Uplisting, Smoobu, Beds24, Avantio, Octorate, AvaiBook, Hosthub, Zeevou, Hostify, Smily (BookingSync), Elina, Resly, Homhero, Streamline, Escapia, CiiRUS, and essentially every Airbnb-connected system — syncs listing content, photos, prices, availability, and reservations through Haven’s direct Airbnb integration: the same data the PMS already publishes there. The only via-Airbnb difference: Haven bookings and manual blocks close dates via the Haven iCal feed added in the PMS, not a reservation-write API.
Plum’s help centre lists full direct integrations with Rentals United, SuperControl, BookingPal, NextPax, Avantio, Guesty, BookingSync (Smily) and Hostaway and light ones with Hostify, Kross Booking, Octorate, Living Parisian, Host Hotel Systems, Your Rentals and Silverbyte: availability and nightly prices sync on every connection, listing content, photos, fees and discounts on the full ones, and house rules, cancellation policy and guest communications on none; other hosts paste iCal links, as of October 2026.
Stripe pays out on its standard schedule (two business days in the US after a first payout of 7–14 days), scheduled payouts to your bank, and you can collect payment yourself if you prefer.
Paid on the closest Friday 24 hours after the guest checks in — a genuine strength — with stays over 30 days handled differently and payouts withheld during a dispute, as of October 2026.
A visits-to-booking conversion funnel with traffic-source attribution, plus first-party session replay with rage/dead-click detection.
No host-facing visitor funnel or session replay is documented on Plum’s public pages, as of October 2026.
The Haven Assistant, pinned to every page of your dashboard, changes your sites and settings from a plain-language request — pages, copy, design, photos, domains, listings, rates and calendar, upsells, guest CRM and remarketing, and email settings — and you approve each change before it ships; for anything it does not change directly, it walks you there step by step. Or connect ChatGPT or Claude through Haven’s MCP server and work from there.
Not documented on Plum’s public pages as of October 2026.
One grounded assistant on every property site, multi-unit site, guidebook, and custom domain (private stay details only after booking). Every reply graded, gaps grouped into insights with cited chats, one-click Add context fixes it across all sites; hosts train it by chatting with their own sites.
Plum’s matchmaking team answers guest enquiries by hand — a strength of its model; no AI assistant is mentioned on its homepage or help pages, as of October 2026.
A blog on every site, plus Blog Autopilot: on a weekly to monthly schedule Haven runs a real research pass — the queries people search about your area, the pages that rank and what they miss — reads the organiser, park, venue, and tourism-board pages it will cite, writes only from those verified facts and your listing, has an editor check every claim, and drafts the post for your review or publishes it with a Sources list, sitemap entry, and IndexNow ping. Keeping your own website? Embed the same blog with a two-line widget.
Not applicable to a marketplace listing.
AI social reels built from your own listing photos, clips and guest reviews, with a storyboard you approve before anything is spent; narrated property stories read by natural ElevenLabs voices; and custom one-minute instrumental soundtracks composed from the property’s photos, likely guests, location and brand. Download-ready MP4s for Instagram, Facebook and Meta ads.
Not documented on Plum’s public pages as of October 2026.
Turnover cleans and upsell jobs become tasks automatically, offered to your own cleaners and chefs by SMS, WhatsApp, or email — Y/N/DONE replies, a no-login job page, photo proof, backup escalation, and Stripe payouts.
No turnover or upsell task system is documented on Plum’s public pages as of October 2026.
Tasks → History keeps every finished clean on every listing for good. Search notes, steps and problem reports; filter by listing, cleaner and dates; browse every photo in one grid; download full size or each clean as a zip with a timestamped manifest for an insurance or damage claim.
Not documented on Plum’s public pages as of October 2026.
Localized pages in up to 5 languages with per-language URLs and hreflang for structured indexing.
Your home is presented inside Plum’s own site; the languages Plum publishes in are not documented on its public pages as of October 2026.
A 100-point SEO and AI-search score for every site with a checklist sorted by points gained, live Google Search Console and Bing data, weekly checks that the crawlers behind Google, Bing and Copilot, ChatGPT search, Claude, and Perplexity can read the page, a site llms.txt, IndexNow, image and Vacation Rentals sitemaps, Foursquare listings, and visits from AI assistants tracked as their own channel.
Your listing is indexed as part of Plum Guide’s site, not as your own.
Your listings appear in Haven’s plain-language AI stay search and in its open search API and MCP server for ChatGPT, Claude, and other assistants — each result links travelers to book direct with you, with no commission or guest fee.
A premium, curated audience and a human matchmaking team behind almost 75% of bookings — a genuine strength; discovery happens on Plum and ends there. No AI search feature is mentioned on its public pages as of October 2026.
Connect Airbnb, your PMS, or an iCal feed and every place gets a free Haven site in Haven’s AI guest search, the Haven app, and the catalog AI assistants read. No listing fee, no commission, no guest fee — guests send booking requests, Haven emails you each one, and you pay only to accept.
Listing is free and there is no subscription, but only about the top 3% of homes reviewed are accepted, a one-time onboarding fee of £300, €300 or $400 plus sales taxes comes out of the first payout, and Plum is then paid per booking, as of October 2026.
A no-code branded site per listing or multi-unit group, custom domain, and built-in Stripe checkout with instant book or request-to-book — the free Haven site becomes your direct booking site the moment you subscribe.
Your home is a page inside Plum Guide with Plum’s checkout and the Plum Award; no website builder or checkout for a site of your own is documented, as of October 2026.
Keep your current site and embed Haven’s booking widget (a script and one div, works in WordPress, Squarespace, Wix, or React), blog widget, or multi-unit search widget; guidebooks, CRM, screening, upsells, and taxes all work alongside it.
Nothing embeds on your site, and the Host Agreement’s parity rule reaches it: your own website may not list a higher nightly rate or extra-service fee than Plum, as of October 2026.
Search answers come from the calendar and rates you sync, checked against your own rules, and the total on the card is the total at checkout. Prices are never shown without dates.
Guests see one price that includes Plum’s booking fee and applicable taxes before they book, and availability and nightly prices arrive by pasted iCal links or a PMS or channel-manager connection — on Plum’s site, for Plum’s guests, as of October 2026.
Beautiful, design-forward branded pages built to convert — no theme picker. It just works.
Every home uses Plum’s listing layout and editorial voice — part of its curated brand; you supply the home, not the design.
Lodging taxes itemized on every booking and aggregated for filing, taxes shown before checkout, and a guest display currency picker.
In some locations, such as Paris, Plum calculates, charges and remits tourist tax itself; elsewhere a host can have Plum calculate it and charge guests at booking, or manage it locally, with the tax shown separately in the earnings breakdown and no platform fee on it. Fees are quoted in GBP, EUR, USD, DKK and ILS and the site shows one currency at a time; a guest display-currency picker is not documented, as of October 2026.
Per-stay door codes and climate automation from the booking, with the code delivered through the guest guide.
Not documented on Plum Guide’s host pages as of October 2026.
One Click Ads: Haven writes short-term-rental-tuned Google Search and ChatGPT ads, you set the daily budget, and Haven runs them for you (Meta rolling out) — no agency retainer.
The onboarding fee covers the creation, merchandising and advertising of your listing, and Plum’s matchmaking team guides guests toward homes — a strength of its model, on its channel; no ad product a host controls is documented, as of October 2026.
Import reviews from OwnerRez, Airbnb, Vrbo, or a file, collect testimonials, and link a Google Business Profile so guests are asked for reviews that show on your site.
Guests rate their stay from 1 to 5 in a post-stay survey and positive feedback (4 or 5) is emailed to the host; whether feedback appears on the listing, and any export to a site of your own, is not documented, as of October 2026.
Haven Communities: shared regional pages that list member stays and exchange reciprocal backlinks with your site.
Homes live on Plum Guide’s site; no backlink or community program is documented as of October 2026.
Discount codes, weekly and monthly, early-bird, last-minute and direct-booking discounts with a “Saving $X booking direct” pill; branded e-gift cards sold in the guidebook and redeemed at checkout; stay credits instead of refunds.
Early-bird (booked 90+ days out), last-minute (under 5 days), weekly (7+ nights), monthly (28+ nights) and custom date-range discounts plus a non-refundable rate option, all within the parity rule; promo codes, gift cards and stay credits are not documented, as of October 2026.
Revenue, occupancy, ADR and RevPAR against last year, booking pace, pricing health, gap and orphan nights, booking sources, a report builder with CSV exports, and a weekly digest.
A host dashboard with an earnings breakdown and downloadable invoices; occupancy, pace or booking-source reporting is not documented, as of October 2026.
Multi-unit and brand sites with room types and property profile pages, custom domains, and professional email on your domain.
Homes appear inside Plum’s site with a host name and profile picture; no storefront of your own, custom domain or email on your domain is documented, as of October 2026.
Partner mode: manage clients’ listings and sites from one console, with client billing and a shared or separate PMS connection.
Managers list through Plum’s PMS and channel-manager connections or its API, with an Account Manager for adding properties; a manager console with owner billing is not documented, as of October 2026.
PriceLabs dynamic pricing integration plus a Calendar AI assistant that changes rates, minimum stays, and blocks from a plain-language request.
Plum’s help centre says it does not support dynamic pricing at the moment; hosts can opt in to Price Syncing, which mirrors their Airbnb prices, as of October 2026.
Haven’s phone web app — bookwithhaven.com on a phone, added to the home screen, with nothing to install from an app store — runs the same plain-language stay search on the same API as bookwithhaven.com/stays.
Not documented: Plum’s homepage links no App Store or Google Play app and its help centre has no app articles, as of October 2026.
Starter includes 1 property, Growth 10, and Pro 50. Each additional property is $3.99/month.
No subscription — listing is free, each home pays the one-time onboarding fee, and Plum is paid per booking, as of October 2026.
Choose Haven if…
- You want to own the guest relationship: real emails, a CRM, remarketing and loyalty that bring guests back direct at 0% commission.
- You want your own terms — the cancellation policy, rental agreement, ID check, deposit and house rules you decide — and your own direct rate, with no parity rule reaching your website.
- You want to be found everywhere, not on one marketplace: your own domain, Haven’s AI stay search, Google, ChatGPT and Claude — while your Plum Guide listing stays live.
- You sell more than the stay: early check-in, experiences, add-ons, gift cards, loyalty — sold at your checkout and in your guidebook with 0% commission.
Consider Plum Guide if…
- Your home is in the luxury tier and you want the demand that a vetted, Plum Award-badged listing and a human matchmaking team bring; Haven is built to run alongside it, not instead of it.
- You value a curated marketplace handling guest enquiries, ID verification, payment and disputes, and you are comfortable with its fee structure, parity rule and host terms.
- You want a payout the Friday after check-in and a marketplace that reports a cancellation rate well below the industry’s.
- You host occasionally and do not want to run a business: no website, no CRM, no terms of your own.
Haven vs Plum Guide
Frequently asked questions
Build your direct booking site free
Configure your Haven site as long as you like — you only pay when you’re ready to publish and take bookings. No per-booking commissions.
Comparison based on publicly available information about Plum Guide as of October 2026. Product features and pricing change frequently — check Plum Guide’s public website for their latest details. Plum Guide is a trademark of its respective owner; this page is not affiliated with or endorsed by Plum Guide.