Mojito Hill

Mojito Hill is where TimberHill started: Tom and Hillery bought it in May 2021 and renovated the pool in deep navy tile chosen to mirror the sea on the horizon. The deck has new patio furniture, chaise lounges, table seating for four and a gas grill for sunset cookouts; at night the pool lights up. Inside, the four-poster king suite opens through French doors onto the deck, the shower is an oversized marble one built for two, and the kitchen has granite counters, modern appliances and the obligatory Keurig latte machine. The couch pulls out for extra guests. There is an on-island manager, and Tom and Hillery answer email, text and phone at any time. Rated 4.99 stars across 139 Airbnb stays.